Six ways to boost a digital appeal that’s failing to meet targets

If a digital appeal isn’t hitting targets, here are six things you can do to boost a digital appeal starting today.
Table of Contents
    Add a header to begin generating the table of contents

    Whether digital fundraising is a new strategy for your charity, or you’ve been running digital campaigns for some time, one thing remains the same. Past data should be assessed to set comparable and realistic targets before any appeal begins.

    The key benefit of a digital appeal over an offline appeal is that you don’t need to wait until the last donation is received before analysing results.

    Using an integrated system which provides real-time reporting allows a charity to track email open rates, click-through rates, donations received and key campaign milestones daily.

    1) Understand the data

    SupporterHub has a comprehensive data analysis and reporting tool that helps charities define the success of campaigns based on previous results and donor history.

    If it looks like the appeal is tracking below target, investigate individual giving history to identify whether major donors have given and when they’re likely to donate. You can also assess previous campaigns to identify the point of the appeal that the bulk of donations were received. This might be after the follow-up or even on a specific day of the week or month.

    You can track these highs and lows from previous campaigns to identify whether you’re truly off track or if the appeal hasn’t yet reached its peak.

    2) Adjust campaign messaging

    If the digital appeal isn’t hitting the mark and donors aren’t responding to email headlines or clicking through to the website, you can easily make adjustments before the follow up is sent. Perhaps you need to change the copy or simplify the email so supporters know exactly how they can support the cause.

    Nothing is set in stone with a digital appeal, take full advantage of the flexibility and make sure the campaign is truly meeting all the donor’s needs.

    3) Engage community support

    If your campaign doesn’t look like it’s going to reach targets, approach local businesses or community groups and propose a matched giving campaign.

    Not only will this highlight the community support behind your campaign, but it can also encourage donors to give knowing their gift will have double the impact. Businesses also like the opportunity to support a local charity and show existing customers how they’re giving back to a cause bigger than themselves.

    4) Refer to your database

    Your database is the key to unlocking the fundraising door. Analyse donor habits and make sure you’ve contacted them at the time they like to give and according to their communication preferences. If donors prefer the personal touch yet they’ve received a generic email, pick up the phone and contact them directly.

    SupporterHub is a donor management platform that helps charities build better relationships with supporters to increase fundraising outcomes. It offers valuable insight into every donor to help charities utilise intelligence and reach fundraising targets.

    5) Run a social media campaign

    Social media campaigns are cost-effective and can be implemented quickly and with minimal disruption. If your appeal isn’t reaching the desired audience, launch a targeted social media campaign to extend reach and increase results instantly.

    6) Communicate with supporters

    If a campaign isn’t reaching targets, communicating directly with past donors is the best way to find out why.

    Pick up the phone, arrange a face-to-face visit (following social distancing guidelines) and get to the bottom of why past donors have chosen not to support you.

    Digital campaigns allow charities to track and monitor progress from the moment the appeal is sent. If an appeal isn’t performing as well as it could be, researching analytics provided through SupporterHub will help you make continual adjustments until targets are reached.

    To find out more about our FREE trial, click

    Free Guide:

    10 Proven Fundraising Tactics of High-Growth Charities for 2025

    Limited resources, growing demands, and fierce competition for donor attention can make fundraising a struggle…

    But it doesn’t have to be this way.

    Discover how successful Australian charities are raising more funds, engaging donors better, and saving precious resources.

    Free Guide:

    The Ultimate 50-Point Fundraising Checklist for Australian Charities

    Running successful fundraising campaigns shouldn’t be guesswork.

    Limited time, tight budgets, and increasing competition for donor attention make fundraising challenging. But it doesn’t have to be.

    Let us help you with our comprehensive checklist covering from pre campaign essentials to post-campaign analysis.

    Donor Giving Made Easy

    Afterpay + Supporterhub

    More Donations, Less Friction – SupporterHub Now Accepts Afterpay for Donor Payments!

    Charity CRM Software

    Book A Demo

    Want a quick go-through of the platform or discuss a custom request? Book a 1:1 demo to let us cover your needs.

    Book a Demo

    Book A Demo